The SCOTX Report

Texas Supreme Court Weekly Digest
September 9, 2026

Opinions Issued

24-0794·Petition For Review

SPECTRUM GULF COAST, LLC v. CITY OF SAN ANTONIO, ACTING BY AND THROUGH CITY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARD

  • The parties' 1984 pole-attachment agreement's "all laws" clause incorporates later-enacted statutes affecting either side's rights or obligations—including PURA's rate-discrimination and rate-ceiling provisions—regardless of whether the agreement itself technically "renews" each year.
  • The Public Utility Regulatory Act applies to this agreement, and CPS Energy's practice of invoicing Spectrum and AT&T at the same rate while collecting only from Spectrum violates the statute's ban on discriminatory pole-attachment pricing.
Read full breakdown

Cases Taken Up

Granted for review, set for oral argument, or rehearing granted — not yet decided.

No cases were newly taken up this week.

Other Orders

Denials, dismissals, rehearing denied, argument scheduling, abatements, and other routine orders.

Denied Motions for Rehearing

  • 23-0244 — TEXAS COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY v. KEN PAXTON, ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS, AND SIERRA CLUB
  • 24-0102 — JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. v. CITY OF CORSICANA AND NAVARRO COUNTY
  • 24-0205 — HUFFMAN ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLC AND PRAIRIE CAPITAL, LLC v. MAURICE COLTER AND NI-IDA COLTER
  • 24-0782 — RYAN BUSSE, JOSH KLOSTERMANN, RUSSEL KLOSTERMANN, LAYNE KLOSTERMANN, MITCH THOMAS, OLIVIA RINCONES, ROBERT RINCONES, RUBEN RINCONES, ENRICA RINCONES, ANGELITA GARCIA, ADELAIDA GARCIA, ANICETO GARCIA, BETTY GARCIA, RAILEY RINCONES, GARY BUSSE, ALISON SAVAGE, AND LYFORD CONSOLIDATED INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT v. SOUTH TEXAS INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT
  • 24-0834 — AMBER CARDEN AND WILLIAM DUNCAN MCGEE v. MINTON, BASSETT, FLORES & CARSEY, P.C.
  • 24-0924 — MV TRANSPORTATION, INC. v. GDS TRANSPORT, LLC
  • 24-0966 — TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY v. ROBERT CHRISTOPHER CALLAWAY
  • 24-1060 — THE STATE OF TEXAS v. CITY OF MCALLEN, ET AL.
  • 24-1069 — SOREN ALDACO v. BARBARA ROSE WOOD AND THREE OAKS COUNSELING GROUP, LLC D/B/A THRIVEWORKS
  • 25-0161 — PRABHAKAR GOPALAN v. ANDREA MARSH

Denied Petitions for Review

  • 25-0502 — LARRY EDGAR ESTRADA AND MAYER BROWN LLP v. CITY OF HOUSTON
  • 25-0802 — FARRAH ARSENIA AGUSTIN-BUNCH v. TEXAS MEDICAL BOARD
  • 25-0820 — PAWN TX, INC. D/B/A CASH AMERICA AND FIRSTCASH HOLDINGS, INC. v. HENRY JIMENEZ, JR.
  • 25-0968 — CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD’S, LONDON SUBSCRIBING TO POLICY N0. BOI80PG1901304, CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD ’S, LONDON SUBSCRIBING TO POLICY NO. BOI80PGI902568, ET AL. v. TRT HOLDINGS, INC. AND OMNI HOTELS MANAGEMENT CORPORATION D/B/A OMNI HOTELS AND RESORTS
  • 25-1021 — IN THE INTEREST OF D.M.W. AND J.J.W., CHILDREN
  • 25-1071 — YELP, INC. v. STATE OF TEXAS
  • 25-1102 — JEREMIAH T. VANCE v. DISCOVER BANK
  • 25-1122 — JAMIE LIN v. PADMANEE SHARMA, M.D., PH.D.
  • 25-1135 — JONATHAN HOBSON, JR. v. COMMISSIONERS COURT OF PALO PINTO COUNTY, TEXAS
  • 26-0006 — RYANN ZELLER v. GARY ALLEN, TOM OIL MONCRIEF, AND GLORIA MONCRIEF HOLMSTEN, AS TRUSTEES OF THE 1966 TRUST OF WILLIAM ALVIN MONCRIEF AND ELIZABETH BRIGHT MONCRIEF
  • 26-0063 — SMITH COUNTY, TEXAS v. BAKER & COMPANY CONSTRUCTION, LLC
  • 26-0149 — ANTHONY F. VACCARO, JR. v. THE LINCOLN NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
  • 26-0181 — AA POLLO, INC. D/B/A EL POLLO LOCO AND ANIL YADAV, INDIVIDUALLY v. BITTERS JSEL, LLC
  • 26-0194 — PAYCHEX, INC. v. AUTOLOTTO, INC.
  • 26-0202 — ALI DAVOUDI v. KATHY LEHNE AND ALI FAZELI A/K/A SEYED FAZELI
  • 26-0217 — SETH KRETZER v. GREAT VALUE STORAGE, LLC AND WORLD CLASS CAPITAL GROUP, LLC
  • 26-0248 — HON. PAT CURRY, STATE REPRESENTATIVE FOR HOUSE DISTRICT 56 AND CURRY FOR TEXAS (A CAMPAIGN) v. COURAGEOUS CONSERVATIVES PAC
  • 26-0252 — JOHNNIE E. HARGRAVE v. LAKE CCC, INC. AND BRECHA ROJA LAND CO., LLC
  • 26-0271 — IN THE MATTER OF J.C., A JUVENILE
  • 26-0284 — C.Q. v. TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES
  • 26-0315 — IN THE MATTER OF D.A., A JUVENILE
  • 26-0331 — ALANA GRILLIER v. DISCOVER BANK
  • 26-0338 — SERGIO SANTOS, ANNE SANTOS, BILLY LIMMER, BRENDAN M. HIERS, KAREN R. HIERS, MIGUEL CARRILLO, VANESSA MARTIN DEL CAMPO, MOHAMMAD AFZAL SIDDIQUI, REHANA P SIDDIQUI, AND RANDY MULHOLLAND v. ENCINO RANCH HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
  • 26-0340 — DAVID AND CONNIE EVANS v. MB HARBOUR, LTD. AND HARBOUR MANAGEMENT, LLC
  • 26-0348 — BEXAR APPRAISAL DISTRICT v. ROLLING OAKS MALL LLC
  • 26-0351 — JESUS TORRES v. MARQUIS CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, LLC
  • 26-0352 — GRIFFIN ENERGY LAW, PLLC v. ROBERT D. BILLINGSLEY
  • 26-0383 — IN THE INTEREST OF K.H., K.H., K.H., AND E.H., CHILDREN
  • 26-0386 — EVANS RESOURCES, L.P. v. PETROPLEX ENERGY, INC.
  • 26-0434 — IN THE ESTATE OF TEDDY JACK WRIGHT A/K/A TED WRIGHT, DECEASED
  • 26-0472 — MICHAEL A. POHL AND THE LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL A. POHL, PLLC v. LANCE CHRISTOPHER KASSAB AND LANCE CHRISTOPHER KASSAB, P.C. D/B/A THE KASSAB LAW FIRM
  • 26-0496 — VENABLE'S CONSTRUCTION, INC v. ASPEN MIDSTREAM, LLC
  • 26-0500 — AFFIRMATION HOLDINGS, LLC v. CLEAR PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC
  • 26-0513 — IN THE INTEREST OF K.D.C., A CHILD
  • 26-0555 — ANNA KONG v. TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES
  • 26-0572 — BENEFICIENT F/K/A THE BENEFICIENT COMPANY GROUP, L.P., BENEFICIENT MANAGEMENT, LLC, BENEFICIENT MANAGEMENT PARTNERS, L.P., AND THE BENEFICIENT MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC v. SHELDON STEIN
  • 26-0597 — IN THE INTEREST OF D.J., A CHILD
  • 26-0620 — THF PARTNERS, LLC v. LUIS GONZALEZ, AND EBGL HOLDINGS, LLC
  • 26-0622 — IN THE INTEREST OF E.T., E.T., E.T., E.D., CHILDREN
  • 26-0634 — MARK GOLOBY AND RICHARD VEGA v. LESLEY BRIONES, ADRIAN GARCIA, LINA HIDALGO, RODNEY ELLIS, AND TOM RAMSEY, ALL IN THEIR OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS MEMBERS OF THE HARRIS COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' COURT
  • 26-0639 — KENEDY COUNTY WIDE SCHOOL DISTRICT v. KELLY HANCOCK, TEXAS COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS, IN HIS OFFICIAL AND INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY
  • 26-0640 — IN THE INTEREST OF B.E.S.D. AND T.D.G., CHILDREN
  • 26-0668 — IN THE ESTATE OF SALLY HOOD COYLE, DECEASED
  • 26-0768 — POLARIS INDUSTRIES INC. v. SEAN MATTHEW MALONEY

Denied Petitions for Writ of Mandamus

  • 25-1002 — IN RE WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INSURANCE COMPANY, ET AL.
  • 26-0182 — IN RE CRESTON LAWRENCE LEONG AND AMERICAN MEDICAL RESPONSE AMBULANCE SERVICE, INC.
  • 26-0266 — IN RE HERBERT KOBAYASHI
  • 26-0292 — IN RE HEATHER CALDWELL AND RODD CALDWELL
  • 26-0320 — IN RE MATTR US INC.
  • 26-0326 — IN RE ADAM KING
  • 26-0337 — IN RE MARA HOLDINGS, INC.
  • 26-0399 — IN RE PAULA M. MILLER
  • 26-0423 — IN RE NEIL HESLIN, SCARLETT LEWIS, DAVID WHEELER, FRANCINE WHEELER, JACQUELINE BARDEN, MARK BARDEN, NICOLE HOCKLEY, IAN HOCKLEY, JENNIFER HENSEL, DONNA SOTO, CARLEE SOTO PARISI, CARLOS M. SOTO, JILLIAN SOTO-MARINO, WILLIAM ALDENBERG, WILLIAM SHERLACH, ROBERT PARKER, AND ERICA ASH
  • 26-0430 — IN RE ETHAN ALLEN-SCOTT MITCHELL
  • 26-0464 — IN RE RICHARD VEGA
  • 26-0489 — IN RE VHS SAN ANTONIO PARTNERS, LLC D/B/A ST. LUKE'S BAPTIST HOSPITAL
  • 26-0508 — IN RE LEVI HARDY
  • 26-0541 — IN RE CARL DAVID ADAMS
  • 26-0807 — IN RE LAURA SALINAS FLORES AND DANIEL MUÑOZ